Setting the Scene
📖 Setting the Scene
Three times between 1679 and 1681, Parliament tried to pass a bill excluding James, Duke of York, from the succession. Three times they failed. The Exclusion Crisis was the greatest constitutional battle of Charles II's reign — a fight over whether Parliament could determine who would be king. On one side stood the "Whigs," convinced a Catholic king meant tyranny. On the other, the "Tories," who believed in divine right and hereditary succession. Charles, using all his political skill, defeated the Exclusionists without another civil war. But the crisis revealed how fragile the Restoration settlement really was.
History glossary
- What was the Exclusion Crisis?
- 1679-81: three successive Parliaments tried to pass Exclusion Bills to bar Catholic James, Duke of York, from succeeding to the throne. Charles dissolved all three Parliaments rather than allow the bills to pass. This was the most serious constitutional crisis of his reign.
Should Parliament be able to change the succession — or is the hereditary principle sacred?
Earn the mark scheme marks
📝 Exam Technique: "How far do you agree?"
Example: "Charles II successfully handled the Exclusion Crisis." How far do you agree? (12+4 SPaG marks)
Agree: Charles prevented exclusion without civil war. He used procedural tactics (dissolving Parliament), French money (financial independence), and let Whigs discredit themselves. James succeeded peacefully in 1685 — the immediate crisis resolved.
Disagree: He didn't solve the underlying problem — fear of a Catholic king. His "victory" depended on French money (dependence on a foreign Catholic power). The Tory Reaction created bitter enemies. James's reign showed the problem was postponed, not solved — James was overthrown in 1688.
Judgement: Short-term success, long-term failure? Charles died in his bed and achieved his immediate aim. But the religious division he failed to resolve destroyed his brother's reign within three years.
Now try it yourself
Quiz · Question 1 of 10
Why did Whig MPs attempt to pass the Exclusion Bills between 1679 and 1681?
Tap an answer to check it