🌟 The City That Cannot Be Destroyed
🌟 The City That Cannot Be Destroyed
The speaker left her homeland as a child. She carries a single image: a city bathed in sunlight. The news reports it is under tyrants, perhaps at war. It does not matter. Every time the city is threatened, her memory of it grows brighter. The oppressors say she has no right to it. She combs its hair. She gives it her language. She takes it dancing. Carol Rumens builds a poem about the power of memory to outlast political violence — and the identity that survives displacement.
Rumens opens with a speaker who arrived in a new country as a child, carrying a mental image of the city she left: "There once was a country… I left it as a child / but my memory of it is sunlight-clear." The phrase “sunlight-clear” is precise: not just clear, but illuminated, warm, made permanent by
Earn the mark scheme marks
🧠 Memory Aid — The BRAND Arc
Remember The Emigrée’s argument with BRAND:
- B — Branded by sunlight: the childhood memory is permanent, involuntary, irremovable
- R — Reality of tyranny acknowledged — but it cannot reach the memory
- A — Active bond: the speaker combs the city’s hair, loves its eyes — not passive nostalgia
- N — Named city, unnamed: the deliberate anonymity universalises displacement
- D — Dancing defiance: the city takes the speaker dancing through walls; the accusers fail
Each letter follows the poem’s argument: the brand (memory) survives the reality of tyranny because the relationship is active; the unnamed city becomes universal; defiance is the final word.
Now try it yourself
Quiz · Question 1 of 10
In *The Emigree*, what does the phrase **'my city hides behind me'** most clearly suggest about the speaker's relationship with her homeland?
Tap an answer to check it