The Recession Nobody Talks About
📖 The Recession Nobody Talks About
By the summer of 1937, Franklin Roosevelt was convinced he had won. Unemployment had fallen from 25% to 14%. Farm incomes were up. The banking system had stabilised. Industrial output was rising. It was time, FDR believed, to balance the budget — to prove the New Deal had worked and that the federal government could now step back.
He was catastrophically wrong. By the autumn of 1937, unemployment had jumped back to 19%. Industrial production fell 33% in just a few months. Americans called it the "Roosevelt Recession" — and they blamed FDR directly. What had happened? The New Deal's job creation had been funded by government spending. When FDR cut that spending, the recovery collapsed, revealing that the economy still had no independent foundation. It was still entirely dependent on federal money.
The Roosevelt Recession of 1937-38 is the most important piece of evidence in any debate about whether the New Deal succeeded or failed. It proved that unemployment in 1937 was the product of government spending, not genuine recovery — and that only continued, massive spending could keep unemployment down. That spending would come, but not from the New Deal. It would come from World War Two.
Earn the mark scheme marks
🧠 Memory Aids: New Deal Success and Failure
The "Traffic Light" verdict on the Three Rs:
- GREEN — RELIEF: Success. CCC (2.5m), WPA (8m), nobody starved. Direct, visible help to millions.
- AMBER — RECOVERY: Partial. Unemployment fell from 25% to 14%, but was still 14% in 1937. Roosevelt Recession set things back. Only WW2 finished the job.
- GREEN — REFORM: Success. Social Security Act still exists. Glass-Steagall prevented banking crashes for 66 years. Wagner Act transformed workers' rights.
Key numbers for the essay:
- 25% — unemployment when FDR took office (1933)
- 14% — unemployment in 1937 after four years of New Deal
- 19% — unemployment after Roosevelt Recession (1938) — it went UP
- 1.2% — unemployment in 1944 after WW2 production (not the New Deal)
- 10.5 million — CCC (2.5m) + WPA (8m) = people directly employed
"The New Deal kept America alive until WW2 could cure it" — This is a memorable way to summarise the consensus verdict. It's not technically a mnemonic, but it captures the nuance perfectly: the New Deal was necessary but not sufficient. Use this phrase in your conclusion.
Who was left out? The "BWSN" test:
- B — Black Americans (excluded from Social Security, AAA hurt sharecroppers)
- W — Women (excluded from or underpaid in work programmes)
- S — Sharecroppers (evicted when landowners took AAA payments)
- N — Native Americans (received some help under Indian Reorganization Act but limited)
Now try it yourself
Quiz · Question 1 of 12
Approximately how many young men did the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) employ?
Tap an answer to check it