Knowledge Organiser: Geographical Decision-Making Skills
The 6-Stage Framework
- 1. Define the issue precisely
- 2. Identify all stakeholders (RAVES)
- 3. Gather evidence from resources
- 4. Evaluate options (decision matrix)
- 5. Consider values and trade-offs
- 6. Reach a justified decision (3C)
RAVES Stakeholder Analysis
- R — Role: who are they?
- A — Attitude: for/against/why?
- V — Values: what matters to them?
- E — Evidence: what data do they use?
- S — Significance: how much power?
3C Decision Structure
- Claim: state your decision first
- Criteria: most important factors + why
- Conclusion: acknowledge trade-offs + justify
- Link to broader frameworks (sustainability, national policy)
- Use specific data from named figures
Key Terms to Use
- Stakeholder — affected by / influences decision
- Trade-off — what you sacrifice for the chosen option
- Option appraisal — systematic comparison of options
- Weighted criteria — prioritising some factors over others
- Sustainable development — balancing present and future needs
- DECIDE SMART — the full 11-step checklist
Common Mistakes
- Stating a decision without justification: Always use the 3C structure — Claim your decision, explain the Criteria that matter most, then acknowledge the trade-offs in your Conclusion
- Ignoring stakeholder conflicts: Examiners expect you to show that different stakeholders have opposing values — present at least two contrasting perspectives before reaching your decision
- Using only one piece of evidence: A strong decision answer draws on multiple named figures or data points from the resources provided — never rely on a single statistic
- Treating all criteria as equally important: Real decisions involve weighted criteria — explicitly state which factors you prioritise and why (e.g. long-term sustainability over short-term cost)
- Failing to acknowledge trade-offs: Every decision involves sacrificing something — name what is lost by choosing your preferred option to show evaluative thinking
Memory Aid
There are 11 key steps in the complete decision-making process. The mnemonic DECIDE SMART gives you all 11 in order — use it as a checklist before you begin any decision-making answer. Letter Step The Key Question D Define the decision clearly "What exactly is being decided? Where? By whom? By when?" E Evidence from the Resource Booklet "Which specific statistics support or challenge each option?" C Consider ALL stakeholders "Who is affected? Do not skip the ones you disagree with." I Identify the trade-offs "What does each option sacrifice? Who loses out with each choice?" D Decision: state it clearly first "Sentence 1 of your answer = your recommendation." E Explain your reasoning "Why these criteria? Why do they matter for this specific place?" S Stakeholders: RAVES analysis "Role — Attitude — Values — Evidence — Significance" M Matrix: compare options systematically "Score all options against the same criteria. Weight your priorities." A Acknowledge opposing views "What is the strongest argument against your recommendation?" R Reach a justified conclusion "3C: Claim → Criteria → Conclusion with trade-offs" T Trade-offs: state explicitly what you sacrifice "Explain why the gain is worth the loss — in geographical terms." Memory trick for DECIDE: The first six letters cover the core framework steps — what you do before writing. The last five letters (SMART) cover how you execute the answer — what you do while writing. Decide, then write SMART.