Test yourself on Decision Making Skills with exam style questions, marked instantly.
Flashcards that come back just before you would forget them.
A revision plan that remembers what you know and shows what to do next.
See which topics you have nailed and which need another look.
Quiz yourself on Decision Making SkillsGet your flashcardsBuild my revision planTrack my progress✅ Reaching a Justified Decision — The 3C Structure
The decision question is typically worth 8–12 marks and has the most variable student performance of any question on the paper. The difference between a Level 1 answer (2 marks) and a Level 3 answer (8–10 marks) is not usually knowledge — it is structure. The 3C structure gives you a repeatable framework that consistently produces Level 3 responses.
The very first sentence of your answer should state your decision unambiguously. "I recommend Option B — partial development of 10 turbines on the modified layout." Do not build up to your decision over three paragraphs. Students who bury their conclusion at the end lose marks because the examiner may not follow the argument. State the decision, then justify it.
The criteria are the factors you used to reach your decision, and crucially, why those particular factors deserve priority. "The most important criteria are: (1) achievability of Wales's legally binding 2035 carbon targets; (2) long-term economic benefit to an area with 7.2% unemployment; and (3) maintenance of the community cohesion that enables future development." Note that criteria should be geographical concepts linked to specific evidence — not just a list of things.
This is the hardest part — and the most important. "Option B achieves approximately 60% of Option A's carbon saving. The sacrifice of 10 turbines' worth of energy output is justified because Option A faces a 68% opposition rate (Figure 6) that would almost certainly trigger planning appeals delaying approval by 3–5 years. Over a 20-year turbine lifetime, Option B approved and operating within 18 months produces more total energy than Option A delayed until Year 5. The trade-off I am accepting is lower immediate carbon saving in exchange for achievable, legally defensible, community-supported development."
The Strategic Trade-off Argument
Notice the structure of the Option B justification above. It does not say "Option B is better because it's less divisive." It says: "Option B is better because the long-term carbon saving over a 20-year period may actually exceed Option A's due to the delays caused by legal challenges." This is a strategic argument — it uses geographical reasoning (timescales, feasibility, systemic effects) to justify a trade-off. This level of thinking is what separates Level 2 from Level 3.
You can also justify a decision by linking it to broader geographical frameworks:
- Sustainable development: "Option B best meets the Brundtland definition of sustainable development by balancing present energy needs against preserving the community's ability to engage in future development projects."
- The development continuum: "For a rural area with 7.2% unemployment, Option B provides economic diversification without the risk of damage to the tourism sector that sustains the local economy — a form of balanced development appropriate for this context."
- National policy alignment: "Wales's Future Generations Act (2015) requires public bodies to consider long-term wellbeing. Option B best delivers long-term wellbeing by avoiding community division while still contributing to legally binding carbon targets."
Quick Check: Write the opening sentence of a 3C structure decision answer recommending Option C (alternative site) for the wind farm decision.
Example: "I recommend Option C — development of a wind farm on the brownfield industrial site 15 km from the village — as it best balances the need for renewable energy development against the environmental and community impacts that make Options A and B unsustainable in this location." (Note: the answer states the decision clearly, identifies the key criterion balance, and links to geographical concepts — all in one sentence. This sets up the criteria and trade-offs to follow.)
Make this stick
Signing in gives access to all PrepWise features.