Options Analysis — Building and Using a Decision Matrix

Test yourself on Decision Making Skills with exam style questions, marked instantly.

Flashcards that come back just before you would forget them.

A revision plan that remembers what you know and shows what to do next.

See which topics you have nailed and which need another look.

Quiz yourself on Decision Making SkillsGet your flashcardsBuild my revision planTrack my progress

📊 Options Analysis — Building and Using a Decision Matrix

Once you have identified the stakeholders and gathered the evidence, you need a structured way to compare the possible courses of action. A decision matrix is a tool used by planners, geographers, and governments to evaluate multiple options against multiple criteria simultaneously. It is not a magic answer machine — it is a thinking tool that ensures you assess every option by the same yardstick.

The Four Options — Wind Farm Case

Any complex decision typically has 3–4 genuine options. For the wind farm:

  • Option A — Full development (20 turbines, original site): Maximum energy output, maximum income for the farmer, maximum carbon saving. But maximum visual impact, highest local opposition, and the greatest risk of a successful planning appeal that delays everything by 3–5 years.
  • Option B — Partial development (10 turbines, modified layout further from village): Reduced energy output (approx. 60% of Option A), but also reduced visual impact and noise. More likely to achieve planning consent without legal challenge. Likely to retain community support from both the farming family and a majority of residents.
  • Option C — Alternative brownfield site (former industrial land, 15 km away): Minimal landscape and community impact. But the site is in an adjacent planning authority's jurisdiction, wind speeds average only 6.1 m/s (below the 7 m/s viable threshold), and infrastructure costs would be 40% higher due to grid connection distance.
  • Option D — No development (status quo): Zero direct impact on the community. But Wales misses its legally binding 2035 renewable energy targets; the area loses the economic benefits; and the energy company may appeal a refusal, creating a longer, more contentious process than granting partial consent.

Building the Decision Matrix

The matrix scores each option against each criterion, then weights the criteria by importance. The weighting is the critical intellectual step — it forces you to state your priorities explicitly, which is exactly what the examiner wants to see.

Criterion Weight Option A (20 turbines) Option B (10 turbines) Option C (Alt. site) Option D (None)
Carbon saving / energy output 30% 9/10 6/10 3/10 0/10
Community acceptance 25% 3/10 6/10 8/10 9/10
Economic benefit to area 20% 9/10 5/10 2/10 1/10
Environmental impact 25% 4/10 6/10 9/10 10/10
Weighted total 100% 6.35 5.90 5.45 4.75

Weighted total = sum of (score × weight) for each criterion. E.g. Option A: (9×0.30) + (3×0.25) + (9×0.20) + (4×0.25) = 2.70 + 0.75 + 1.80 + 1.00 = 6.25. These weights reflect a priority on hitting carbon targets and economic benefit to the area.

What the Matrix Tells You — and What It Does Not

The matrix suggests Option A scores highest — but this does not automatically make it the right answer. A decision matrix is only as good as the weights you choose. If the community accepts a decision through a legitimate, consultative process, they are far more likely to support future renewable energy projects. A 58% opposition rate against Option A could lead to years of legal appeals that delay carbon savings anyway. A geographer does not accept the matrix output blindly — they interrogate it, challenge the assumptions, and explain why the weighting choices are defensible.

This is exactly the kind of thinking the examiner is looking for in a Level 3 answer.

Quick Check: A decision matrix awards Option A the highest score, but a student recommends Option B instead. Is this acceptable? Explain your answer.

Make this stick

Signing in gives access to all PrepWise features.

PrepWise is a trading name of A3M Quality Solutions Limited, registered in England and Wales, company number 14959172. Registered office: 202 Stroud Road, Gloucester, GL1 5LA. ICO registration ZC267069.