Antarctic vs Arctic Management — Comparing Governance Systems

Test yourself on Cold Environments: Threats & Management with exam style questions, marked instantly.

Flashcards that come back just before you would forget them.

A revision plan that remembers what you know and shows what to do next.

See which topics you have nailed and which need another look.

Quiz yourself on Cold Environments: Threats & ManagementGet your flashcardsBuild my revision planTrack my progress

⚖️ Antarctic vs Arctic Management — Comparing Governance Systems

Factor Antarctica Arctic
Main governance body Antarctic Treaty System (ATS) — 54 signatories Arctic Council — 8 member states (non-binding)
Legal status Binding international treaty; territorial claims frozen No binding treaty; sovereignty of member states applies
Military activity Banned by Antarctic Treaty Article I Permitted; Russia has actively militarised the Arctic since 2015
Mineral extraction Banned until at least 2048 (Madrid Protocol 1991) Active and growing: oil platforms, pipelines, natural gas extraction
Marine management CCAMLR (1982): ecosystem-based fishing quotas; Ross Sea MPA (1.55 million km²) Central Arctic Ocean Fisheries Agreement (2021): 16-year fishing ban in high seas; no MPA equivalent
Tourism regulation IAATO (voluntary industry association) sets guidelines; 74,000 visitors/season (2022–23) National regulation only; 1.2M visitors/year to Svalbard
Territorial claims Frozen under Article IV — neither recognised nor renounced Active competing claims (Russia, Canada, Denmark/Greenland) under UNCLOS
Indigenous peoples No indigenous population — not relevant Inuit, Saami, Nenets and others have Permanent Participant status at Arctic Council
Enforcement Voluntary compliance only; no independent enforcement National jurisdiction; virtually no international enforcement
Climate change addressed? Not in treaty framework — requires global action Not in Arctic Council mandate — acknowledged in Kiruna Declaration (2013) but no binding action
Overall assessment Strong framework for what it covers; major gap on climate change and tourism Weak framework; competing national interests undermine collective action; Russia's 2022 actions have paralysed the council

The fundamental difference: Antarctica was governable as a global commons because no one lived there and extraction was not yet economically viable when the treaty was signed. The Arctic's governance failure reflects competing national interests that pre-date any agreement.

Quick Check: Explain one reason why Antarctica is better managed than the Arctic.

Make this stick

Signing in gives access to all PrepWise features.

PrepWise is a trading name of A3M Quality Solutions Limited, registered in England and Wales, company number 14959172. Registered office: 202 Stroud Road, Gloucester, GL1 5LA. ICO registration ZC267069.